BIG UPDATE: Massive Red Flags Emerge in the Disappearance of Lily and Jack Sullivan—What Investigators Ignored Might Be the Key to Everything
In the hauntingly quiet town of Pictou County, Nova Scotia, something unthinkable happened—and the red flags are piling up faster than answers. Lily Sullivan, 6, and her brother Jack, 4, vanished from their rural home in broad daylight on May 2, 2025. No screams. No struggle. No trace.
But what if they never actually vanished?
In this deep-dive true crime exposé, we unpack every red flag, every silence, and every suspicious inconsistency in what’s quickly becoming Canada’s most disturbing missing children case in decades.
RED FLAG #1: The Missing Amber Alert
The RCMP refused to issue an Amber Alert. Why? Because “there was no credible evidence of abduction.” Despite the fact the children had vanished from their home and hadn’t been seen since the previous day, authorities instead floated the theory that the kids may have “wandered off.”
No footprints. No trail. No sightings. Just vanished.
But the Amber Alert never came.
Even their own mother, Malikia Brooks-Murray, later said, “I wish an Amber Alert had been issued… just to let everyone know they are missing.”
RED FLAG #2: The Timeline Was Wrong for a Month
Originally, police and the family claimed the last sighting was April 29th—four full days before the 911 call. But on May 28th, the RCMP quietly updated the case timeline:
Lily and Jack were seen in public with family on May 1st.
This isn’t a minor clerical correction.
This changes everything.
It means the original story was either mistaken—or manipulated.
THE TAPE: “I Know Exactly What Happened to the Kids”
And then came the audio. A man, identified as Darren Gettys, is caught on tape saying:
“I know exactly what happened to the kids… The kids are alive. The kids are probably not in Nova Scotia now.”
The RCMP hasn’t confirmed the tape’s authenticity, nor commented on Gettys’ connection. But locals report he’s closely tied to both the family and the ongoing investigation.
So if the children are alive… where are they? And who is hiding them?
RED FLAG #3: 53 Minutes of Silence
At 10:00 AM on May 2, Malikia called 911 and said she’d “drifted back to sleep” after hearing her kids play. But what happened between 9:00 and 10:00?
We now know the back door wasn’t forced, the children’s clothes and toys were untouched, and only two footprints were found—right outside the home. Forensic experts have called this “highly improbable,” especially given the rainy conditions that morning.
Two kids, wet ground, zero tracks? Impossible.
RED FLAG #4: The Polygraph Nobody Talks About
Multiple sources have confirmed that Daniel Martell, the children’s stepfather, took a polygraph test—but results have not been released. RCMP has remained tight-lipped.
Why?
What were the questions?
And why hasn’t the public been told the outcome?
RED FLAG #5: The Blanket by the Pipeline
Daniel later claimed Lily’s blanket was found near a boot print along the pipeline trail—miles from the home. But that discovery was never included in any RCMP report or press release. Why?
Was it irrelevant, or was it inconvenient?
The Bigger Picture: Were They Ever Truly Missing?
All signs suggest this case may not be about a typical disappearance—it could be a coordinated cover-up. And the biggest red flag?
No arrests. No suspects. No bodies.
Just silence.
What Comes Next?
We’re only scratching the surface. In the next episode of True Crime: Clock, we’ll reveal:
A sudden name change in the family
Surveillance tapes from Landown Station
And the bizarre disappearance of Malikia herself from Pictou County just days after the kids went missing
🎥 If You’re Watching This: You Can Help
🔔 Subscribe to True Crime: Clock
💬 Comment below: Do you believe Lily and Jack are still alive?
📣 Share this story. Their case must not go cold.
Your theory might help crack the case.
Because someone knows the truth.
And time is running out.
